databases – How to simplify the query qualification?

Given the following DB and query :
enter image description here

enter image description here

Now if we need to simplify the query qualification, here is the answer from the book (Principle of distributed database systems, third edition) :

enter image description here

My question is in the highlighted bracket, I think this should be (p1 OR (p2 AND (Not p2))) instead of the one written because we have the following rule :

enter image description here

Is that right ?