display – OSX cmd+tab behavior with multiple windows of same application and monitors

First of all, my question is not answered in any of the questions with the similar titles. My context is a little different.

I have 2 monitors connected to my MacBook Pro. I opened 2 windows of Safari, one for each monitor.

  • On 1st monitor, there’s a Safari window and Application A.

  • On 2nd monitor, there’s the 2nd Safari window and Application B.

  • 2nd monitor is focused on Application B.

  • 1st monitor is focused on Application A.

  • On the 1st monitor, I switch from Application A to Safari using cmd+tab and 1st monitor successfully focuses on it’s own Safari window.

  • But 2nd monitor also switches to it’s own Safari windows instead of keeping the Application B on the screen.

How can I prevent this from happening so 2nd monitor doesn’t switch to Safari as well and instead keep it’s application on its screen?

I already tried all the combinations from Mission Control page but none of them helped me achieve this. Or maybe they didn’t work as they intended to be, I’m not sure if that’s the case.